Apparent bargains raise questions about transparency and consumer trust.
Lisbon, Portugal
Portugal’s consumer protection organization DECO PROteste has warned that several major retailers are advertising Black Friday promotions involving products that were available at lower prices before the sales campaigns began. An investigation conducted in early November identified questionable pricing practices at online stores operated by Auchan, El Corte Inglés, Euronics and FNAC, raising concerns about compliance with Portuguese consumer protection legislation. The findings emerge as retailers intensify promotional activity ahead of Black Friday on November 27, a shopping event that has increasingly expanded into weeks of advertising and discounted offers.
The investigation examined selected products on November 2 and 3, comparing advertised prices with historical records to determine whether promotional claims represented genuine savings. DECO found examples in which products included in Black Friday campaigns were more expensive than they had been shortly before the promotions began. The organization also identified potentially misleading comparisons involving manufacturers’ recommended retail prices, which can create the impression of substantial discounts without demonstrating actual reductions from previously charged prices.
One example involved Samsung Galaxy Buds4 Pro wireless earbuds sold by FNAC. During the retailer’s Black Friday campaign, the headphones were listed at €249.99, although DECO’s monitoring showed that the same product had been available for €199.99 between October 12 and 18. The difference represented an increase of €50 compared with the earlier price. While FNAC had not advertised an explicit price reduction for that particular product, its inclusion in a promotional campaign illustrated how consumers could associate seasonal marketing with savings that were not necessarily available.
Other retailers presented similar concerns. At El Corte Inglés, a robotic pet-monitoring device was offered for €149.99 during a campaign advertising reductions of up to 40%, despite having previously been available for approximately €139. Auchan advertised a robotic vacuum cleaner for €160.99 while displaying a substantial reduction against its recommended retail price, even though the same appliance had cost €144.89 the previous day.
Euronics provided another example involving an AEG electric oven. The retailer listed the appliance at €629 and displayed a recommended retail price of €809, alongside a claimed 22% reduction. However, DECO’s research indicated that the oven had been sold for €573.73 in late October, approximately €55 less than its promotional price. The consumer organization also challenged the retailer’s representation of the lowest price charged during the preceding 30 days.
These examples expose a fundamental distinction between promotional advertising and measurable economic savings. A product described as discounted may still cost more than it did before a campaign began, particularly when the comparison relies on a manufacturer’s suggested price rather than the retailer’s actual selling history. For consumers making purchasing decisions under time pressure, such presentations can distort perceptions of value.
Portuguese legislation establishes specific requirements intended to prevent these practices. Since 2022, retailers advertising price reductions have generally been required to calculate discounts using the lowest price charged for the product in the same establishment during the preceding 30 consecutive days. The rules also require clear disclosure of the new price and the relevant previous minimum price, allowing consumers to evaluate whether the advertised reduction corresponds to a genuine saving.
DECO argues that compliance remains inconsistent despite repeated warnings and regulatory reforms. Its spokesperson, Nuno Pais de Figueiredo, told Euronews that financial penalties have not always provided sufficient incentives for retailers to abandon questionable practices. The organization has repeatedly called for stronger inspections by Portugal’s Food and Economic Security Authority, known as ASAE, which is responsible for enforcing commercial pricing regulations.
The findings do not establish that every Black Friday promotion is misleading, nor do they represent final regulatory rulings against the retailers examined. DECO acknowledges that genuine bargains remain available, particularly when buyers understand a product’s price history and compare offers across competing sellers. The central concern is whether advertised savings accurately reflect what customers would otherwise have paid.
The issue has become increasingly relevant as digital commerce changes purchasing behavior. Online retailers can adjust prices rapidly, present personalized promotional messages and employ countdown clocks or limited-availability claims to encourage immediate decisions. Although these commercial techniques are not inherently unlawful, their combined effect can make independent price assessment more difficult, especially when consumers rely on prominent discount percentages rather than historical pricing information.
For businesses, the controversy carries consequences extending beyond short-term sales performance. Retailers depend on consumer confidence to sustain repeat purchases, particularly in competitive markets where customers can compare prices across multiple platforms. Promotional strategies that generate immediate transactions but undermine trust may eventually weaken customer loyalty and expose companies to reputational and regulatory risks.
DECO recommends that consumers identify intended purchases in advance, examine historical prices and avoid decisions driven exclusively by large discount labels. Its online price comparison tools allow users to examine changes across different periods and assess whether a particular offer represents a meaningful reduction. Consumers who identify suspected irregularities can also submit complaints through established Portuguese consumer protection channels.
The investigation illustrates a broader challenge in modern retail: technological efficiency and sophisticated marketing do not automatically produce greater transparency. As Black Friday expands beyond a single shopping day, the credibility of promotional campaigns increasingly depends on the accuracy of their underlying price comparisons. The essential measure of a genuine discount remains straightforward: what consumers actually save, rather than how prominently retailers advertise the percentage.
Beyond the Numbers, the Consequences.