Behind celebrity fame lies an often invisible emotional cost.
NEW YORK
Hailey Bieber has revealed that years of relentless online harassment led her to experience suicidal thoughts during one of the most difficult periods of her public life. Speaking at The New York Times DealBook Summit in New York on November 18, the model and founder of Rhode described how hostile social media comments, public confrontations and constant comparisons with singer Selena Gomez affected her emotional well-being. Her testimony offers a troubling perspective on the psychological consequences of digital hostility, particularly when speculation surrounding celebrities develops into sustained personal attacks.
During her conversation with journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin, Bieber recalled receiving repeated messages encouraging her to take her own life, alongside incidents in which strangers confronted her in public. She described an environment in which criticism extended far beyond ordinary disagreements or commentary about her professional activities. At the height of the harassment, she began questioning whether her absence would be preferable to continuing to experience such overwhelming hostility.
The controversy originated largely from public speculation surrounding her relationship with Justin Bieber, whom she married in 2018 following his previous relationship with Selena Gomez. Online discussions frequently portrayed the two women as romantic rivals, encouraging comparisons that intensified whenever either appeared publicly or shared material on social media. Bieber’s account describes the consequences of this environment, although it does not establish that Gomez personally encouraged the harassment or that every hostile message originated from her supporters.
The singer herself previously attempted to discourage the hostility. In March 2023, Gomez publicly acknowledged that Bieber had contacted her about receiving threats and abusive messages, urging people to stop directing hatred toward her. The intervention demonstrated that the widely circulated narrative of a personal rivalry did not necessarily reflect the positions expressed by the women involved. Nevertheless, speculation about their relationship continued to attract attention across entertainment media and digital platforms.
One particularly revealing example involved informal comparisons between the celebrities that appeared in everyday public spaces. Bieber recalled seeing tip jars at Starbucks locations inviting customers to choose between her and Gomez, an experience she presented as evidence of how deeply the rivalry narrative had entered popular culture. Although such gestures might appear trivial to outside observers, their cumulative significance becomes different when combined with persistent threats, public scrutiny and repeated personal humiliation.
Her reflections also challenge a familiar assumption about celebrity culture: that financial success, public recognition and professional opportunity provide sufficient protection against emotional distress. Bieber has established an influential business presence through Rhode, the beauty company she founded in 2022, while maintaining a substantial international audience. Yet the same digital visibility that helped support her commercial success also exposed her to criticism that she found difficult to ignore.
Rather than presenting herself as unaffected by public opinion, Bieber acknowledged that she remains sensitive to how others perceive her. She explained that she continues to experience insecurity when comparing herself with people online, despite having developed greater resilience through years of public exposure. This distinction is important because emotional resilience does not necessarily eliminate vulnerability, nor does professional achievement prevent someone from experiencing psychological distress.
The entrepreneur has consequently adopted a more deliberate approach to managing her relationship with social media. She described efforts to regulate the time she spends online, recognizing the difficulty of establishing boundaries when digital platforms remain constantly accessible. Her comments suggest that the challenge involves more than simply avoiding negative material, particularly for someone whose professional responsibilities are closely connected to online communication and public engagement.
Motherhood has also influenced her perspective. Bieber, who welcomed her son Jack Blues with Justin Bieber in 2024, expressed a desire to maintain open conversations with her children about insecurity, emotional challenges and the pressures associated with digital environments. Rather than concealing her own experiences, she hopes that acknowledging vulnerability will help establish a relationship in which difficult feelings can be discussed without shame or unnecessary judgment.
Beyond the personal circumstances, the testimony raises broader questions about the responsibilities of digital platforms and the behavior of online communities. Repeated harassment can transform entertainment-oriented discussions into environments where personal hostility becomes normalized, especially when audiences interpret speculation as established fact. The speed with which digital narratives circulate can also make it difficult for individuals to challenge misinformation or establish boundaries around their private lives.
The relationship between social media use and mental health remains complex, and individual experiences cannot establish universal psychological outcomes. Nevertheless, Bieber’s account illustrates why sustained harassment deserves attention beyond celebrity reporting. Public visibility does not diminish the seriousness of threats or emotional suffering, and the presence of a large audience does not make personal attacks an acceptable consequence of professional success.
Her disclosure also highlights the limitations of placing responsibility entirely on individuals to become more resilient. Personal strategies for managing digital exposure can be valuable, but they do not eliminate the need for effective moderation, responsible public communication and stronger social norms against harassment. The distinction matters because expecting people to tolerate repeated abuse risks treating harmful behavior as an unavoidable characteristic of online participation.
For Bieber, speaking publicly about a painful period represents an effort to explain the emotional reality behind years of speculation. Her experience challenges audiences to reconsider how quickly fictionalized rivalries can overshadow the humanity of the people involved. It also raises a question extending far beyond entertainment: whether digital societies can preserve freedom of expression while recognizing the consequences of sustained hostility toward identifiable individuals.
Behind Every Fact, a Deeper Story.